Typing in some domains, I stumbled across a landing page, that looks like a Google search results page.
The parking company, is FirstLook.com, using a Yahoo feed.
Not only have I never seen this lander, but I’ve never heard of FirstLook.
According to its site, FirstLook.com:
“Is the industry pioneer in domain traffic optimization and monetization. Our long history in this space, spanning over 8 years, has allowed us to develop the most advanced optimization platform available today.”
So maybe its just me, but how can this company be a pioneer in domain traffic optimization and monetization and be unknown?
Moreover, FirstLook.com claims to have a “state of the art optimization platform”, which it call First Yield, which they describe as “the most sophisticated yield technology available in the marketplace today”
The Google like landing page is just, one of many they have, (here is a standard lander) but it sure seems like they are asking for trouble.
Big Trouble.
On the other, the company claims to power Jackpot.com a great domain and the game site, Uproar.com
Has anyone out there heard of these guys, or better yet, tried them out and what are your thoughts on this type of landing page?
eastcoastdomains says
Formerly Vendare Media
Johnny says
So……who’s gonna’ try them out…..LOL?
Check out their PimpMySpace.com ……that’s a horrible site they are pushing.
UDRPtalk says
MHB, Can you explain how Google would be harmed by someone cloning their layout?
Domainers says
Here’s some interesting info to follow:
FirstLook.com contact email is @navigationcatalyst.com
On the bottom of Jackpot.com, there’s a link to PimpMySpace.com.
PimpMySpace.com is registered to Navigation Catalyst Systems
From this article in Wikipedia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Navigation_Catalyst_Systems
“In 2007, Navigation Catalyst Systems, along with its affiliate
registrar Basic Fusion, was sued by Verizon for the registration and
domain tasting of 1,392 domain names incorporating Verizon’s
trademarks (Verizon California, Inc. v. Navigation Catalyst Systems,
Inc., 2008 WL 2651163 (C.D. Cal. June 30, 2008).”
MHB says
UDRP
Google can show harm if people think they are on a Google page.
The parking company in my opinion is risking a lawsuit from Google.
Eric says
I would agree but I believe they would need to have something branded google for a UDRP to stick. Some CSS is not enough to scream UDRP
MHB says
Eric
Not talking about UDRP for this one.
Suit for trademark infringement is what they could be looking at.
Steve M says
. . . but even if TM couldn’t be shown/proven, likely trade dress could be.
Richard says
If you look at the top right, the image resembles Picasa a Google product! The color scheme can’t really become a trademark issue I believe, but having an image that resembles Picasa can be a definite case! Since Google does not have the absolute right to the color scheme of the site, but they do have a right to the Picasa logo if they indeed have a trademark on it.
owen frager says
That is the exact page you get when you use AdSense for domains.
D says
Hm but it is just standard Google parking lander (formerly on url like apps5.oingo.com/…) i.e. Snapnames on their fresh catches use it too wwwwetter.com and lots of other larger domainers with own Google feed, this is pretty known design…
Richard says
It isn’t, you can clearly see if you hover the links that it says overture. As you previously stated in your article. As well as the fact that this does not actually look identical to a Adsense for Domain page. This is an Adsense for Domains page I quickly found from searching for one.. http://www.blogstarawards.com/
MHB says
Richard
You are correct and the page you site is not anything like the Google like page in my post
Nidal Elkadri says
http://www.OnlineFinancing.com was purchased during the Feb 20th 2008 T.R.A.F.F.I.C. conference in Vegas by a company called Vendare Media / Netblue. (Vendare and Netblue merged and now are called Connexus and firstlook.com is bought by them too).
OnlineFinaancing.com was the 82nd domain in the live domain auction and was sold to bidder paddle #462. The domain sold for a price tag of $17,500 USD. The sale was confirmed and reported on DnJournal.com on 5/6/08.
OnlineFinancing.com sells on SnapNames.com for $5000
What? This is getting interesting!!
When ownership changed to Vendare Media / Netblue after payment from winning the domain at auction for $17.5K, the domains expire date was 5-10-2009. This date also stayed that way until the domain name expired on 5-10-2009.
MediaWebPlus.com (Nidal & Nassib Elkadri) bought this domain name and we think it is a big hit and Vendare Media, firstlook.com are not able to manage their portfolio of domains even we are not able to contact them.
FX says
I too believe Richard is correct with his assessments. These layouts are not new either, they’ve been using same layouts or variations of them for the last few years.
MHB, unless your intention was to get more info about these guys or give them some free publicity, this is not the kind of a post i would expect to see from you.
Jay says
What do I think of the page? I think it will work as generally the plain jane pages work the best and the reason google pages look that way as they have stated time and again that they don’t want to entertain/confuse the user with images just pass them off to the advertiser as quick as possible, at least they have an “inquire” link so you could actually sell a domain unlike google.
James says
Why Reinvent the wheel?
when you can use time tested, best converting landing page in the world …
jb says
I’m surprised you never heard of them. Navigation catalyst ring a bell? These guys were probably the third biggest tasters after oversee and belgiumdomains through their basic fusion registrar. They probably own around 500k domains so you cannot realy dispute their pioneering status.
robert says
I would not ever do business with this company, that is, unless you want to lose a lot of money.
Howard Neu says
The real problem here is copyright infringement, not trademark infringement. By using the same look as GOOGLE, they are looking at a huge Federal law suit, not UDRP.
MHB says
Howard
Besides the legal implications, don’t domainers and parking pages have a bad enough reputation without this kind of nonsense?
This type of stuff ultimately hurts all of us
FX says
Do these 2 logos really look alike to you guys ?
http://cdn.firstlook.com/custom/images/ftpdest/elements/logo-gen.gif
http://picasa.google.com/images/logo.jpg
not to mention picasa has nothing to do with search, thus where is the confusion ?
landing pages, these 2 clearly look and function different enough to me.
http://www.blogstarawards.com/
http://www.crushes.com/
Howard. can you copyright the look of the page ??
Howard Neu says
Howard. can you copyright the look of the page ??
Yes you can
MHB says
Fx
You can legally protect the look of a product. This is pretty common.
Check out these recent issues:
schools object and stop bud from issuing bar cans in school colors
http://www.ktvb.com/news/special1/stories/ktvbn-aug2609-fan_cans_bsu.11c639da4.html
Maker’s Mark suing over other liquor companies putting a red wax over their bottle caps: (saying that he resemblance is likely to cause confusion among consumers).
http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5gSJ30TrDUE1VBXpQvATbHD1SOYVAD9ALC6LG0
FX says
So than i have to ask the following
how are these 3 any different
Dont they all look, feel, function in the same way, and have the same colors ?
http://search.yahoo.com/search;_ylt=A0oGklQzXa5KFq8Axqal87UF?p=debt&fr=debt
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=debt
http://www.bing.com/search?q=debt&go=&form=QBLH&qs=n
FX says
just for the record i have nothing to do with Navigation Catalyst or google. Just asking tough questions to educate myself and readers here.
MHB says
FX
No I don’t think so at all.
Other than its a page that has search results they are not copies of each others look.
D says
“I would not ever do business with this company, that is, unless you want to lose a lot of money.”
I did some biz with them and I made lot of money.
nythemes says
ya everyone knows that google,bing, yahoo pretty much look the same, and hundreds of other search engines
in addition: has anyone used OpenDNS before? their page not found results also loook “confusingly similar” to google with the exception of the logo.
Protecting the look and feel of a webpage is not only silly, petty, it’s laughable at best. You can protect the look of your page as easily as car manufacturer’s can protect the color and shapes of their cars, steering wheel, nuts and bolts, ….
Hello?, live in the digital economy,where everything is a copy of a copy, remix of a remix, where SHARING is IN and PROTECTING is OUT, some folks still are stuck in the past and don’t “get it”. Take a look this very blog here “the domains” the design is the same as hundreds of other blogs out there, why don’t you bloggers start suing each other…?
owen frager says
And what is Idea Lab’s VisualSearch.com which has the Google Favicon in its corner but goes to Overture?